Stay or Pay and TRAP Agreements: Are They Worth It?

It is an understandable approach for an employer to want to protect their investment in their employees.  When an employer offers an employee the ability to take advantage of expensive or extensive training that requires the employer to pay a significant amount of money for that opportunity, it only natural that the employer would want to ensure that they receive a return on their investment.  Enter the TRAP or Stay or Pay Agreement. 

Training Repayment Agreement provisions, often referred to as TRAPs, are a form of an agreement between an employer and an employee when the employer offers the employee an opportunity to receive specific training benefits.  In order to ensure that the employer receives the benefit of its bargain, the employer may ask an employee to sign a TRAP agreement which would require the employee to repay the employer for the training costs paid on the employee’s behalf if the employee does not remain in their current position for the time period specified in the contract. 

Stay or Pay agreements are a similar tool used by employers to recoup additional costs incurred for specific employees by an employer.  These Stay or Pay agreements are typically broader than a TRAP agreement and may cover benefits beyond training costs, such as retention bonuses, signing bonuses and other payments to employees that an employer may offer where the payment is contingent on an employee meeting certain tenure milestones. 

While these agreements are not inherently unlawful, many states are scrutinizing their use.  This evaluation of these types of agreements looks at the effect of the agreement from the employee’s perspective and raises a concern among state agencies and courts that the effect of such agreements is to create disincentive for employees to leave their current employment situation and avail themselves of other opportunities.  In other words, they are viewed as creating a damper on the employee’s ability to engage in free trade with respect to their labor.  This is a similar criticism to what has been applied to the use of noncompete agreements. 

For a period of time, the U.S. Department of Labor and other federal agencies have taken a negative view of noncompete agreements.  While the tide has turned a bit on the federal level, many states have passed their own laws relating to the use of these agreements.  At least four states, Colorado, California, New York, and Connecticut, have passed legislation regarding the use of these agreements.  Each state’s statute is unique and contains specific provisions that must be followed in that state to ensure that the agreements are enforceable.  For example, Colorado limits the use of the agreements to training that is more specialized or advanced and will not apply it to on the job or other training that is required for the employee to successfully perform their job.  California’s law expands its focus from training agreements to encompass all types of paid benefits to employees. 

A prime example of a state’s challenge to a TRAP agreement recently occurred in Colorado.  The Colorado Attorney General’s Office sued PetSmart because of TRAPs that they required their grooming employees to sign once they became employed by the company.  With the pet grooming case, the Attorney General called into question PetSmart’s treatment of groomers who they recruited with promises of free grooming training worth about $5500, but then made those same employees sign a TRAP stating that they would be responsible for repaying the cost of the training program if they left PetSmart within the first two years of employment. 

While TRAPs and Stay or Pay agreements are not per se illegal, employers must be careful in how they draft and implement them. The specific terms and conditions set forth in the agreement will make or break whether the agreement will be enforced.  myHRcounsel can assist you in determining whether these agreements are appropriate for your situation and in drafting legally compliant and enforceable agreements.