Employee Personnel Files: What is it and Who can See it?

Employee personnel files are, at their core, a record of an employee’s tenure with their employer.  They contain information regarding the employee’s salary, job performance, training, and other documents that describe an employee’s experience with their employer.  In some instances, an employee personnel file can become a catchall for documents that inexperienced or overworked human resources staff stick in the file because they don’t what else to do with those documents.  Employers often think that the employee personnel file is a business record that is controlled by the employer; after all, it is maintained by the employer, the employer dictates what is placed in the file, and employees are generally given copies of items that have been put into the file or have been created about them.  As part of the belief that the employer owns the personnel file, many employers have policies or practices where they deny employees the ability to review the information in their personnel file.  While it is true that federal law does not give employees the right to review their personnel files, this is not true at the state level. 

Many states, including most recently New York, have enacted laws providing employees the right to access their personnel files.  Each state has their own law and each law has its own terms and conditions for the employee and, in some cases, a former employee to review their personnel files.  A review of the state laws that currently provide that access shows that the laws vary greatly from state to state.  Some states only grant the right to review a personnel file to public employees. Other states require an employee or a former employee the right to access the file after a specific amount of notice to the employer and employers who do not respond and grant the access within the specified time frame can found to have violated the law.  Other states allow employers to charge for any copies of materials in the file that the employee requests, while others limit the type of records that an employee can review as part of their access to the file.

Regardless of the law in your state, this movement by states toward allowing employee access to their personnel files requires employers to take a more proactive approach to the maintenance of employee records and the establishment of the employee personnel file. Recordkeeping is one of the most tedious job duties in human resources.  Most HR staff members have a general idea of what should be contained in the personnel file and what should not be maintained in the personnel file.  For example, I-9 forms and any supporting documentations that is gathered and retained should not be placed in a personnel file and must be stored in a separate I-9 file.  Medical information that is received regarding the employee must be kept in a separate confidential medical file and access to that file should be restricted to only those staff members with a business need to know that information.  Materials received as part of the employee’s application and hiring process, such as background check results, reference letters, and interview notes, should be maintained in a separate file.  Records of any workplace investigations involving the employee should be maintained in a separate file and should not be included in the personnel file. Despite this, it is always a good idea to review the requirements of what must be included in a personnel file and what should be excluded. 

What then must or should be included in a personnel file?  The test of what belongs in a personnel file is that it be job-related. Examples of job-related information that belong in a personnel file include:

• Resume

• Employment application

• Offer letter

• Job description

• List of company-issued property

• Handbook acknowledgment

• Licenses/certifications

• Attendance records

• Direct deposit authorization
• Salary history

 • Records of promotions, demotions, transfers

• Performance goals

• Performance review forms

• Training records

• Discipline notices

• Exit interview form

• Resignation letter

In reviewing a personnel file, it is important to review the contents of the file to ensure that there is no information that is included in the personnel file that would violate the law or provide access to confidential information that may support an employee’s claim of discrimination, mistreatment, or other negative employment actions.  Supervisor’s notes, EEO information and other unofficial records should not be included in the personnel file.  If an employee is the subject of discipline or is accused of wrongdoing, the file should only include the final disciplinary notice or documentation of the outcome of the investigation.  It should not include interview notes or communication between the supervisor and HR regarding the alleged wrongdoing.

What is maintained in the personnel file is as important as what is excluded from the personnel file. myHRcounsel can assist you in ensuring that your personnel files are accurate reflections of an employee’s service and do not include any information that could violate the law or the employee’s right to privacy.  We can also assist you in appropriately responding to an employee’s request to review their personnel file both under state law and in light of the circumstances leading to the request.